When the PC becomes a parenting problem
Stefanie Olsen
C-Net News
October 11, 2007
When Hemi Zucker's 8-year-old son
began refusing to leave the computer for the dinner
table, things came to a head.
His wife, frustrated by the many hours a week their
son plays games online and his vehemence to stretch
out the fun, banned the computer altogether.
"The computer is the 'c' word in our house," said
Zucker, a Los Angeles resident.
The Zuckers aren't alone with the creeping feeling
that their kids are spending too much time online.
About a third of parents believe the Internet sucks up
too much of their child's time, according to at least
two studies this year. And an annual report from the
University of Southern California's Annenberg School
Center for the Digital Future shows that number has
risen steadily since 2000, when only 11 percent of
parents cited the issue.
To add perspective, nearly half of parents (48.6
percent) complained that their kids watch too much
television in the 2007 study--the highest level in the
six years of USC's digital future project. So TV
certainly hasn't lost its stature in the home.
It's hard to predict whether the computer will outpace
TV on the list of parental frustrations, but the
studies and trends elevate its status. As more schools
adopt a digital curriculum, children are spending more
time in front of a computer screen at home and school
to complete coursework. That alone could lend to a
feeling among parents that kids are online too much.
But where it gets sticky is that the Internet is also
a hub for socializing, self-expression, play and
time-shifted television, making it irresistible to
more kids.
One parent described the phenomenon like this: "Their
school life, TV life and their social networking is
happening online," said Wayne Crews, a father of four
in Fairfax, Wash. "Nobody knows how to bait a hook,
but they know how to download and install a Windows
file."
So how much is too much? Experts say there's no hard
and fast rule for each family, and it should vary
according to the child's age and school curriculum.
Jim Steyer, founder and CEO of kids media-education
group Common Sense Media, said pre-kindergarten
children should likely stay off the computer
altogether, but older "tweens" may need to spend an
hour or more on the computer each day for homework.
"If it's getting in the way of other activities, like
being outside and spending time with parents, then
it's too much," Steyer said.
Steyer himself has a family rule that bars his kids
from watching TV or playing computer games during the
week because he and his wife want them to play
outside.
How much time online?
On average, more than three-quarters of Americans age
12 and older spend about 8.9 hours online per week, up
about an hour from a 2005 study from the USC-Annenberg
Digital Future Project. But young people, specifically
ages 8 to 18, spend about an hour on the computer and
49 minutes playing video games per day, according to
the nonprofit Kaiser Family Foundation.
Crews, director of technology studies at the policy
advocacy group Competitive Enterprise Institute, said
his daughters, 8 and 11, are addicted to Webkinz, a
virtual world populated by digital pets. But he and
his wife limit the time they can spend playing and
socializing on the site to about an hour a day (the
same time limits they set with TV), so Crews takes a
positive view of their time spent on the computer.
That's particularly important considering the kids are
doing more of their homework online and potentially
watching streaming TV shows over broadband.
"The same way they might be watching TV and look down
at a textbook, now they might be on Blackboard.com (a
school curriculum Web site) and then toggle over to
Webkinz," Crews said.
Crews' wife also limits their 13-year-old son to two
hours a day playing computer games like Halo on the
Xbox.
Crews added: "You don't want them to turn into jelly.
You limit what they do, but I don't think they miss
out on imaginative play by doing things online. They
can get a lot more out of playing Halo than with the
Play-Doh Fun Factory."
Some parents believe the computer is just supplanting
the TV as the predominant screen in the home. But some
industry experts say that the computer is different
because it's more interactive--involving games and
socializing. However, it's similar to TV in that it
often means the child is sedentary. And some research
has shown that computer games and the Internet can be
more addictive than TV viewing.
Bobbie Carlton, director of marketing for Beacon
Street Girls, a kids' social network, said she limits
her boys, who are ages 5 and 10, to one hour of
screen-time--whether it's video games, TV, DVDs or the
computer--per day. And she enforces the time limit by
setting a kitchen timer.
She added that it can be hard to always set a good
example because she's online for work so much. "It's
hard for the pot to be calling the kettle black,"
Carlton said.
Steyer said it's important for parents to set time
limits for children when they're young, even if
they're in preschool, so they know how much time they
can spend online or with TV and video. He added that
parents should keep the computer in a common family
room, and talk regularly with their kids about what
they do on the computer.
Still, the Zuckers aren't alone in taking the computer
away. In 2006, USC reported that almost 50 percent of
parents had withheld Internet use from their child as
a form of punishment.
"Teaching kids that using the Web is a privilege not a
right, that's very important from the beginning
because good media habits can last a lifetime," Steyer
said.

